The Pebble Paradox

Every Antarctic spring, a gentoo penguin waddles across a rocky beach carrying a single stone he’s carefully picked out. He drops it at the feet of the penguin he hopes to build a life with. If it’s accepted, it becomes the first stone of their nest. It’s called pebbling, and I think it’s one of the best leadership lessons in nature.

Now think about a pebble in your shoe. It’s tiny, but it can ruin your whole day. You shift your weight, you limp a little, and pretty soon the whole walk is about that one little rock.

Same small stone, completely different experience. One says, “I noticed you, and I want to build something with you.” The other just wears you down.

When the pebbles end up in our shoes

Years ago at ATB Financial, we put in a new back-end banking system. On paper, it was the right call. In practice, it dumped pebbles into the shoes of thousands of people. A screen took longer to load. Something that used to be simple now needed a workaround. A customer question suddenly had no easy answer. None of it was a catastrophe on its own, but together it was enormously frustrating.

People can carry one pebble with grace, maybe even a few. But when the pebbles pile up faster than leaders remove them, people stop walking with you. They start limping beside you, and eventually some stop walking altogether.

To their credit, ATB’s leaders responded decisively. They stopped all development work and assigned three of our top executives to do nothing but what I now call pebble blasting. Their job was to find the irritants, get rid of them, and report progress to the executive team every week. The message to thousands of frustrated people was clear: we see what you’re carrying, and getting it out of your shoes is now job one.

Culture doesn’t usually collapse in some dramatic failure. It wears down one ignored pebble at a time.

When the stones are gifts

Compare that with my time at Ryzex, long before recognition became a matter of clicks and emojis. We had Aces cards, which were simple handwritten notes colleagues gave each other when someone went above and beyond. Someone had to stop, think about what you did, pick up a pen, and write it down.

People pinned them up at their workstations, so you could walk through the office and see little collections of Aces everywhere. They cost next to nothing, but they built something no compensation plan can buy: the feeling of being seen.

I still remember Liz’s cube. Liz cleaned old refurbished equipment, and she made it look like it had just come off the factory floor. Her cube was covered in Aces, each one thanking her for her care and attention to detail. Every customer who opened a box and found equipment that looked brand new was experiencing Liz’s work. Liz was the brand, and her colleagues made sure she knew it.

Putting the right stones into daily work

Penguins don’t court with grand gestures. They offer one well-chosen stone. At work, that might look like this:

The stone of recognition. A specific, timely thank-you that names what someone did and why it mattered. That’s the Aces card principle.

The stone of attention. Asking a colleague how they’re doing and actually waiting for the answer. Connecting before content.

The stone of inclusion. Bringing someone into the conversation before the decision is made, not after.

The stone of candor. Honest feedback, offered with care. Handled poorly, this one ends up in somebody’s shoe. Handled well, it becomes part of the foundation.

Your challenge this week

Two things. First, take stock of the pebbles your team is carrying and remove one. Just one. Second, offer one intentional stone each day, whether that’s a specific thank-you, a genuine question, or an invitation to the table.

Small stones build nests. Pebbles ruin walks. Which kind you hand to others is one of the most underrated decisions a leader makes.

What will you offer today?

Think Big, Start Small, Act Now, 

- Lorne 

Garrett’s View: I don’t know about you, but more than 90 percent of my day is assisted with a screen, and even physical activities are app reliant. That being said, tangible pebbles that you can toss away or display are pieces of matter that somehow matter even more.

- Garrett 

AI Response: Both halves of Lorne’s argument hold up in the research.

On recognition, Gallup and Workhuman followed nearly 3,500 employees from 2022 to 2024 and found that well-recognized employees are 45% less likely to have turned over after two years. Even so, just 22% of employees say they get the right amount of recognition for the work they do, unchanged from 2022.

On pebbles, Teresa Amabile and Steven Kramer’s diary study (from The Progress Principle) is close to a direct endorsement of pebble blasting. They found that the negative effects of setbacks on inner work life are two to three times stronger than the positive effects of progress, and that small everyday hassles hold more sway than small everyday assists. Their recommendation for leaders is to focus first on eliminating the obstacles that cause setbacks. The Worth of Small Wins: Teresa Amabile and Steven Kramer on The Progress Principle +2


































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































 

Search Blog Posts:

Categories
Month

Follow Us: