Hope is a Practice. Asking is the Move.

Two ideas have been circling me this week.

The first belongs to Kari Grain, a University of British Columbia scholar who writes largely about social change, though I think leaders inside organizations need her framing just as badly. Her book, Critical Hope, makes an argument I keep returning to. Hope is not simply a feeling you happen to possess. It is a practice you take up deliberately, especially on the days you least feel like it.

The second belongs to Angela Duckworth, the author best known for Grit, writing this week about a trait she keeps finding in people who accomplish consequential things. They ask for help. Not occasionally. Habitually.

At first pass, those two ideas live in different neighborhoods. The longer I sat with them, the more convinced I became that they are one idea seen from two angles.

Hope is Not a Mood and it is Not a Veneer

Grain is blunt about the limits of ordinary optimism. Hope on its own, unaccompanied by action, is naive at best. At its worst it quietly talks us out of the agency we actually have. Her version of hope is messy, uncomfortable and full of contradictions. Anger and grief are given a seat at the table rather than shown the door. It also fits like a glove with a value I deeply honor: self accountability.

What she is rejecting is what I would call the leadership veneer, the bright coat of paint we brush over a hard truth because we cannot bear to stand in the room with it. I have been seduced by that veneer. I have stood in front of people and implied a certainty I did not have, because the alternative felt like abandoning them. It was not hope. It was anaesthetic, and it wore off by the parking lot. As a newly promoted VP of Sales, well intended and entirely unhelpful, I once handed the board of a public company a polished wish instead of the painful truth.

Critical hope does the harder thing. It looks directly at what is actually happening, names it out loud, and only then asks the question that matters. What do we do next?

The Most Underused Move Available to Any of Us

Duckworth lands on something that sounds soft and is not. The people who do difficult things ask for help far more often than the rest of us assume, and far more often than most of us do ourselves.

We underestimate how likely others are to say yes to a direct request, we underestimate how genuinely willing they are to help, and we overestimate how awkward the asking will feel. Helpers, for their part, underestimate how exposed the asker feels in the moment. This links straight to psychological safety. A team in which nobody asks for help is not a safe team, it is a quiet one.

So the ask does not get made. We grind alone, call it resilience, and quietly run out of steam.

Where the Two Ideas Meet

Here is the connection, and I think it is the whole point of this post.

Critical hope is a practice, and practices are not solo activities. The ask is the smallest repeatable unit of hope in action. It is hope operationalized, reduced to something you can actually do before lunch.

When I ask you for help, I am making three declarations at the same time. I am admitting the reality of my situation rather than papering over it. I am refusing despair, because nobody asks for help on a problem they have already given up on. And I am handing you agency inside my circumstance, which is a form of respect we badly undervalue.

That is why asking feels so exposed. It is not the admission of not knowing that frightens us. It is revealing that we care about an outcome we cannot control on our own.

Read it Through the Character Triangle

If you have worked with me, you know I test most ideas against three questions. This one holds up on all three.

Self Accountable. The ask is my move, not someone else's obligation. Waiting to be noticed is not accountability, it is hoping in the passive voice.
Respectful. A direct ask honors your competence enough to want it, and your autonomy enough to let you answer either way without penalty.
Abundant. Helping lifts the helper. People who say yes feel better afterward. Every ask you make and every yes you give deepens the reservoir the rest of us draw from.

There is a belonging dimension here too. Nothing signals membership faster than being asked. When someone brings you a real problem, you count here. If you want a culture where people feel they belong, start asking them for things that matter.

Five Practices for the Week Ahead

Say the true thing first. Before the ask, name the reality without decoration. “I do not know how this lands and I am not going to pretend otherwise.” Critical hope begins with an unvarnished sentence.
Make one specific ask. Vagueness is the enemy. Not “let me know if you have ideas” but “would you give me thirty minutes on Thursday to work through the pricing call?”
Reach for a dormant tie. The colleague you have not spoken with in four years knows things your current circle does not, and is far more likely to answer than you fear.
Answer generously. A culture of asking collapses without a culture of answering. Protect the yes.
If you lead, go first. Permission to ask never comes from a policy. It comes from watching the most senior person in the room do it without flinching.

The Bottom Line

Uncertainty is not a phase we are passing through, it’s the operating environment. Grain gives us the posture, hope with its eyes open. Duckworth gives us the mechanism, the ask that turns posture into motion. Neither works alone.

Do what is difficult. Name the reality. Then ask.

What is the one ask you have been carrying and have not made yet? Who is it for, and what is actually stopping you?

Think Big, Start Small, Act Now,

- Lorne

Garrett’s View: I wasn’t sure I’d appreciate this blog because my unvarnished optimism has at times been my greatest weakness. I love having hope, yet I certainly can’t depend on it as a workflow. Sayings like “a vision without execution is just a hallucination,” and “by failing to be prepared, you are preparing to fail” exist in truth. Here’s where it gets tricky: Sometimes hope is a crutch for people who refuse to put in the hard work. This is when vagueness is the enemy, because we’re actually talking about a specific, necessary, crucial type of hope that depends on our own capabilities, accountability, confidence, faith in ourselves and those we seek help from. Because we believe we can achieve what we’re hoping for. And, we’re willing to do the hard things to make it happen.

- Garrett

AI Response: Duckworth's help-seeking research lines up well with broader organizational psychology data: Vanessa Bohns' research on the "underestimation effect" found people consistently underestimate their odds of getting a yes to a direct request — in her studies, requesters guessed compliance far below actual observed rates, sometimes by 50% or more. Separately, psychological safety research from Amy Edmondson's work at Harvard — later validated at scale in Google's Project Aristotle study of 180+ teams — found that team psychological safety was the single strongest predictor of team effectiveness, more so than individual talent or resources, largely because safe teams surface problems (and ask for help) earlier rather than letting them compound. On the hope side, Grain's "critical hope" concept draws on a lineage that includes Paulo Freire's "critical consciousness" and C.R. Snyder's hope theory, which found hope scores correlate with goal attainment specifically because hope includes "pathways thinking" (route-finding) alongside "agency thinking" — not just wanting an outcome, but believing you can generate a way to get there.

Hope is a Practice. Asking is the Move.

Search Blog Posts:

Follow Us: